I might have to retire my ACE gifs already.

[adrienne]

He sucked tonight on AI. Sucked hard. He was still beautiful though...

And someone who's getting no love...probably because he doesn't really look the part...is Elliott Yamin. His voice is just AMAZING.

[adrienne]

Oh, and I thought Kellie was great last night. I so have a girlcrush on her, she is just too cute.

[Silver21_Black20]

Ace looks ultra hot with his beanie on.

[Horry For 3!]

He hasn't really sang that well at all

[adrienne]

Oh, I know that by no means does he have the best voice in the compe ion...but last week he worked what he has. (An incredible amount of sex appeal and charm).

[Sonia_TX]

I thought he was pretty good tonight. Not as great as last week though

[SpursWoman]

I don't think he did very well tonight at all ... but Chris is still my favorite.


I really didn't like any of the girls...I think a guy will win this time. Kelly can't sing worth a crap....I wonder how far cute is going to get her?

[ZStomp]

I don't think he did very well tonight at all ... but Chris is still my favorite.


I really didn't like any of the girls...I think a guy will win this time. Kelly can't sing worth a crap....I wonder how far cute is going to get her?

it'll get her on Playboy!

[The sone]

still rooting for mr hung!! she bang! she bang!

[spurs=bling]

i missed it.

[spurs=bling]

still rooting for mr hung!! she bang! she bang!

that was so messed up

[CharlieMac]

Kellie Pickler is ridiculously hot.

[Horry For 3!]

That guy Chris picks out good songs, he picks out pretty recent songs. I like them

[ChumpDumper]

You only like Ace because he's good looking. Just go with it. It's not a crime.

I've seen the last two shows for no particular reason -- I didn't know how good I had it watching curling and ice dancing the past few weeks. My observations:

Women: The two black chicks with the large heads are the best singers hands down, but one is opera fat (a designer mumu is still a mumu) and the other looks like Gary Coleman in drag. Pickle Lady and the Amazon will advance because one is apparently the cutest person alive when she sings with her hair in her mouth and the other one just learned how to put on makeup even though she wore it when playing basketball before coming out to LA. There is also the risk that she would smash the set Godzilla-style if she was ever asked to leave.

Men: The guy who sang Sam Cooke and looks like Martin Tupper's friend from "Dream On" (why the do I remember these things?) and the bald guy with sideburns shaped like violin soundholes are the best singers. That 12 year-old kid who's balls have yet to drop needs to be told that cheek pinching is NOT sex. The Peter Brady lookalike needs to learn that Frank Sinatra was cool singing ANYTHING because he knew he could any woman in the concert hall and she would do all the work and say he was the best ever after it was over. My personal favorite has to be the 38 year-old who obviously was allowed to be a part of "Idol" due to his ties to the Russian mafia. My girlfriend says he looks like a cross between Jay Leno and Michael McDonald. I say he's the love child of Joaquin Phoenix and Captain Kangaroo.

[WilliamHung]

still rooting for mr hung!! she bang! she bang!

Thank you so much!!

she bangs!!!

[Ginofan]

You only like Ace because he's good looking. Just go with it. It's not a crime.

I've seen the last two shows for no particular reason -- I didn't know how good I had it watching curling and ice dancing the past few weeks. My observations:

Women: The two black chicks with the large heads are the best singers hands down, but one is opera fat (a designer mumu is still a mumu) and the other looks like Gary Coleman in drag. Pickle Lady and the Amazon will advance because one is apparently the cutest person alive when she sings with her hair in her mouth and the other one just learned how to put on makeup even though she wore it when playing basketball before coming out to LA. There is also the risk that she would smash the set Godzilla-style if she was ever asked to leave.

Men: The guy who sang Sam Cooke and looks like Martin Tupper's friend from "Dream On" (why the do I remember these things?) and the bald guy with sideburns shaped like violin soundholes are the best singers. That 12 year-old kid who's balls have yet to drop needs to be told that cheek pinching is NOT sex. The Peter Brady lookalike needs to learn that Frank Sinatra was cool singing ANYTHING because he knew he could any woman in the concert hall and she would do all the work and say he was the best ever after it was over. My personal favorite has to be the 38 year-old who obviously was allowed to be a part of "Idol" due to his ties to the Russian mafia. My girlfriend says he looks like a cross between Jay Leno and Michael McDonald. I say he's the love child of Joaquin Phoenix and Captain Kangaroo.

I agree.

I didn't understand why "Sway" was getting all the hate when he did the same as or even slightly better than Ace.

[CharlieMac]

You only like Ace because he's good looking. Just go with it. It's not a crime.

I've seen the last two shows for no particular reason -- I didn't know how good I had it watching curling and ice dancing the past few weeks. My observations:

Women: The two black chicks with the large heads are the best singers hands down, but one is opera fat (a designer mumu is still a mumu) and the other looks like Gary Coleman in drag. Pickle Lady and the Amazon will advance because one is apparently the cutest person alive when she sings with her hair in her mouth and the other one just learned how to put on makeup even though she wore it when playing basketball before coming out to LA. There is also the risk that she would smash the set Godzilla-style if she was ever asked to leave.

Men: The guy who sang Sam Cooke and looks like Martin Tupper's friend from "Dream On" (why the do I remember these things?) and the bald guy with sideburns shaped like violin soundholes are the best singers. That 12 year-old kid who's balls have yet to drop needs to be told that cheek pinching is NOT sex. The Peter Brady lookalike needs to learn that Frank Sinatra was cool singing ANYTHING because he knew he could any woman in the concert hall and she would do all the work and say he was the best ever after it was over. My personal favorite has to be the 38 year-old who obviously was allowed to be a part of "Idol" due to his ties to the Russian mafia. My girlfriend says he looks like a cross between Jay Leno and Michael McDonald. I say he's the love child of Joaquin Phoenix and Captain Kangaroo.

I agree, that little black chick with the famous relative and the pepper haiored guy are really good singers.

[Brutalis]

American Idol.

"How to build a star with money"

[T Park]

That 12 year-old kid who's balls have yet to drop needs to be told that cheek pinching is NOT sex.

And yet, is still a better singer than 90% of the horse on 99.5, that rap bull on 98.5 too.


Kid has more talent than those two station's cd compilations combined EASILY.

[T Park]

American Idol.

"How to build a star with money"

Or finding a star that great music executives wouldn't look for.

[lilmads]

I love Kellie! She's just so bubbly and cute!

Ace looks amazing Unfortunately he didn't do well last night. But Chris is awesome, too! He rocked last night!

[MoSpur]

Ace will make it to the final 3 or 4 because of his looks. As a guy I will admit he is good looking. I like that guy Elliott. He sings really good, but too bad he might not win because of looks. Whoever signs him to a record deal will have to get those teeth fixed and he'll be alright. I like me some Pickler though. She is very pretty.

[adrienne]

Of COURSE I like Ace because he's good looking. Why did you think I was in love with him?

The best voice in the compe ion is Elliott Yamin. I'm serious.

[Horry For 3!]

You only like Ace because he's good looking. Just go with it. It's not a crime.

I've seen the last two shows for no particular reason -- I didn't know how good I had it watching curling and ice dancing the past few weeks. My observations:

Women: The two black chicks with the large heads are the best singers hands down, but one is opera fat (a designer mumu is still a mumu) and the other looks like Gary Coleman in drag. Pickle Lady and the Amazon will advance because one is apparently the cutest person alive when she sings with her hair in her mouth and the other one just learned how to put on makeup even though she wore it when playing basketball before coming out to LA. There is also the risk that she would smash the set Godzilla-style if she was ever asked to leave.

Men: The guy who sang Sam Cooke and looks like Martin Tupper's friend from "Dream On" (why the do I remember these things?) and the bald guy with sideburns shaped like violin soundholes are the best singers. That 12 year-old kid who's balls have yet to drop needs to be told that cheek pinching is NOT sex. The Peter Brady lookalike needs to learn that Frank Sinatra was cool singing ANYTHING because he knew he could any woman in the concert hall and she would do all the work and say he was the best ever after it was over. My personal favorite has to be the 38 year-old who obviously was allowed to be a part of "Idol" due to his ties to the Russian mafia. My girlfriend says he looks like a cross between Jay Leno and Michael McDonald. I say he's the love child of Joaquin Phoenix and Captain Kangaroo.

That dude is 28

[Sonia_TX]

My favorite girl is Katharine McPhee but I also like Paris and Lisa.



As far as the guys go...I really don't have a favorite but I do like Taylor, Ace, Elliott, Sway, Chris (last night was the first time I really liked his performance). Gideon REALLY surprised me last night. I thought he should have been out last week with his version of "Shout" but (I thought) he was awesome last night. I didnt know he could sing like that.