would you trade Tim Duncan to the rights to Greg Oden?

[Lakerfan]

Greg Oden is compared to the next Tim Duncan coming out of college... would you guys ever trade him? Oden is probably the next dominate big man will you take a chance at him if it met to give up Duncan?

[ChumpDumper]

Would you trade Shaq for Brian Grant and Lamar Odom?

[baseline bum]

* sound of crickets chirping *

[Mr. Body]

Would you trade Shaq for Brian Grant and Lamar Odom?

[Leetonidas]

No.

[birdy219]

Trading Tim is out of the question.....NOW. He is one of the few NBA players who you could NOT get true value for. Maybe in 5 years, but he would retire before forcing a trade. Would you trade Kobe Bryant for anyone?

[Quadzilla99]

Would you trade Shaq for Brian Grant and Lamar Odom?

-and Caron Butler who they stupidly gave away for Kwame Brown. To answer the other question-NO!!

[spurs=bling]

[Vinnie_Johnson]

Would you trade Shaq for Brian Grant and Lamar Odom?

That's crazy who would

[Leetonidas]

Trading Tim is out of the question.....NOW. He is one of the few NBA players who you could NOT get true value for. Maybe in 5 years, but he would retire before forcing a trade. Would you trade Kobe Bryant for anyone?

Kobe for LeBron or Wade, but Tim for no one, unless by some odd force of nature we're getting Dwight Howard and LeBron out of it.

[MrChug]

Greg Oden is NOT the next Tim Duncan. The guy is the prototypical center and will be in the NBA. Now he might be a VERY VERY GOOD center, but never will he be considered a versitile leader. I'm a huge fan of the guy, but NEXT to TD, not instead of TD. Tony and someone like Finley maybe, but not TD...F no.

[sa_butta]

Lakerfan
Believe.

Position: Pass-First Guard
Team: San Antonio Spurs
vBookie Cash: $500
Post Count: 18
??

no Duncan is a proven All-star and MVP. This guy could be compared to anyone and I would not accept.

[tlongII]

You would be crazy not to trade Duncan for Oden. He will automatically extend your window of opportunity by at least 10 years.

[TDMVPDPOY]

You would be crazy not to trade Duncan for Oden. He will automatically extend your window of opportunity by at least 10 years.

i trade everyone besides td

[Please_dont_ban_me]

That's crazy who would

Mitch Nutcheck

Then he had the nerve to get on national television after the Heat won it all, and with a straight face say "I would do it all over again the same way".

[Mr.Bottomtooth]

Add Kevin Durant,OJ Mayo, and Joakim Noah then we'll consider thinking about it.

[baseline bum]

You would be crazy not to trade Duncan for Oden. He will automatically extend your window of opportunity by at least 10 years.

Oden's an amazing athlete and a of a shot-blocker, but he doesn't have NBA footwork. He'll most likely be an amazing player of HOF level, but I'd never trade a known quan y like Tim for him, especially considering Duncan is one of the top 15-20 players in league history.

[Please_dont_ban_me]

Now, let's talk Dwight Howard...and maybe I would at least seriously consider it.

[ro_50]

No.

Greg Oden has a chance to become a great one, but the way he talks, don't be surprised if he stays more than one year at Ohio St.

[ducks]

you know what?
oden has bust written all over him
he is not every going to live up to the hype he is getting

let him play a game before you compare him to david robinson

[dknights411]

[Spurologist]

[FromWayDowntown]

you know what?
oden has bust written all over him
he is not every going to live up to the hype he is getting

let him play a game before you compare him to david robinson

The same ducks who thinks Lebron James is overrated?

[ducks]

I like oden right now
he has not done anything to tick me off yet
the only think I do not like is when people compare him to david robinson
LET HIM PLAY A GAME BEFORE YOU SAY HE IS DAVID ROBINSON
besides that david is my favorite player and they will never be a david robinson

[cherylsteele]

There are too many variables to determine that right now.

What happens if Oden has a major injury like a knee blowout or some other catastrophic injury. At this moment.... no...I'd rather have Nazr back....at least we know he stinks.

Now if somewhere down the line he becomes a solid player and develops in college....then you take that into consideration.

If you want to give up Tim...then do it for DRob's boy...at least he has a pedigree.