Would you...

[BuddyHolly]

This trade is just a pull out of my ass, however, would you do it?

Tony
Brent

for

Maggette
Livingston
Williams

[AFBlue]

No....Livingston is overrated

And who is Williams?

[Kermit]

if livingston played up to his potential every night, yes.

[Kori Ellis]

No way.

Livingston isn't that good right now.

[BuddyHolly]

I think Shaun could be something really special.

[Kori Ellis]

I think Shaun could be something really special.

I think Tony is already something special.

[Kermit]

I think Shaun could be something really special.

he could be, but he's too erratic. i'll admit that he has all the talent in the world, though.

[Buddy Holly]

I think Tony is already something special.

I agree.

[MrChug]

Actually, it's not that far fetched. I tried a scenario on TradeChecker that I liked. Tony + Brent for Shaun and Kaman. It worked. We need a big.

[VaSpursFan]

i do not trade tony...he's only going to get better. his ability to finish in the lane over bigs is remarkable. his mid range j has improved greatly. if he extends his range beyong the arc, he's going to be damn near unstoppable. livingston has the athleticism but he's still raw.

[AFBlue]

I've said it before and I'll say it again....

There comes a point when the "big" PG becomes too big & can't guard the 1 spot, and when the "pass-first" PG becomes the "can't shoot" PG who can't provide offense when needed.

Instead of J-Kidd you end up with Shaun Livingston.

[timvp]

This would be a good trade. . .

. . .if the Spurs were trying to win the 2012 championship.

[Buddy Holly]

Brent
Beno
Williams

for

Maggette
Shaun

If only...

[Kermit]

i do not trade tony...he's only going to get better. his ability to finish in the lane over bigs is remarkable. his mid range j has improved greatly. if he extends his range beyong the arc, he's going to be damn near unstoppable. livingston has the athleticism but he's still raw.

he has three-ball range (46% from there this year). his shot just takes a really long time (in nba terms) to come of his fingers (my opinion). i never really see him drive in and pull up (floater doesn't count), although i'm sure it's something he's working on. most of his sucessful jumpshots look to me to be a result of a pass in which he's wide-open.

[boutons_]

Ususally, nobody in the West is gonna help the Spurs. We traded with Knicks last year, Iverson went West. Wally and friends went from Minny to Boston.

I don't have the stats, but aren't most trades nearly always trans-conference?

[Spurs Brazil]

No

[AFBlue]

Ususally, nobody in the West is gonna help the Spurs. We traded with Knicks last year, Iverson went West. Wally and friends went from Minny to Boston.

I don't have the stats, but aren't most trades nearly always trans-conference?

Crappy teams with malcontent players make trades with any team...no matter what conference.