Ya'll are crazy, and hindsight is 20/20! Kidd is a Hall-of-Famer who carried a mediocre Nets team for years! He took that team to the Finals twice (and people make a big deal about LeBron doing it). He made Miki Moore look like a borderline All-star this year!
Having Kidd on the team would have been sort of like an Avery Johnson who was big, could play D, make all-stars out of average players, create Ginobili-like havoc in the passing lanes, effectivly doubleteam, create a dozen easy shot opportunites per game in fast break, and even unload a few 3's once in awhile.
History shows that most great teams have at least two Hall-of-Fame type players. Kidd is one of those, a game-changer who modifies the opponents game plan.
That being said, it has worked out really well for us. Ginobili and Parker are extremely good at what they do, and we are much more versatile than we would have been with Kidd. But I think it's a big mistake to think Kidd and Duncan would not been an effective, and perhaps championship-caliber duo.