I don't see Parker doing this well for the whole year, so I am enjoying it while it lasts. He has had some GREAT games in a row, but he will have to average 20ppg with decent assists and good d to deserve top 5 right now IMO.
I don't know how to compare how good Parker is to other pg's without using some objective stats; scoring, assists, rebounds, team winning. Defense is very hard to quantify and verify. Of course we can say if parker was on a bad team he would be the man and would get comparable stats to some on this list, but I think we all know that AI carries his team, and it is VERY DOUBTFUL that Parker could do the same. Replace any of these : Francis, Marbury, Nash, Lebron, Francis, with Parker, and the team IMO just does not do as well.
Parker is very good, and sometimes great (like tonight against phoenix), but not consistent enough to be the main star on a team yet.
Today's top 5 points (objectively, in terms of overall productivity and wins)
1. Nash
2. Marbury
3. Lebron (point forward, 6th in assists!) Wade if you want to push it.
4.AI with over 7 apg and 28 ppg!
5. Francis with 22 ppg, 6.8 apg, 6 rpg his team is winning.
Bibby is just as effective as Parker today, and has the same numbers. Tinsley has always been a better assists man, but shoots at a poorer percentage. Scores about the same as parker.
In 5 years I think...
Wade, Arenas, parker, Arroyo, Hughes? will be top 5.
Don't forget Bibby and Billups, who will still be effective in 5 years, though probably safe to say Parker will have passed them.
Tinsley is averaging what Parker is in pts and assists, though not as good a shooting percentage.
Remember that Marbury will be 31 in 5 years, he will be in his prime still. Bibby will be 30, Francis 31, Billups 32.
Andre Miller with 15 ppg, shoots .47%, 6 apg, 10th in steals. Under rated.