Spurfan needs to let go of their sentimental/nostalgic attachment to David Robinson..

[Nathan89]

Yep, facts are facts.



That's not a fact, that's speculation.



And more speculation. You can speculate all you want, but I'll stick to facts.

Dirk 1
D-Rob 0

Not fact but it's pretty obvious. Do you speculate otherwise?

Actually those aren't facts
Dirk 1
D-Rob 2

[Nathan89]

How is your claim that Dirk would have never won with those teams a "fact"

Yes it's not a fact but I think it's pretty obvious. Do you think he would have won a ring on those teams?

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

IMO Dirk could have easily won a championship with Dominique Wilkins and Sean Elliott.

[Veterinarian.]

Not fact but it's pretty obvious. Do you speculate otherwise?

Actually those aren't facts
Dirk 1
D-Rob 2

Resort to ring smack when you get ed up the ass in an argument

You've just showed the forum that you're just as ty of a poster as cully

[stretch]

The fact is he would have never won on those Spurs teams that David had.

proof?

link?

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

Plus if Dirk had Dennis Rodman as a teammate, he wouldn't have alienated Rodman by chasing him around with a bible. He would have been grateful for the 15 rebounds per game Rodman got for his team and he would have been OK with Rodman leaving his house on the weekend.

[Veterinarian.]

Plus if Dirk had Dennis Rodman as a teammate, he wouldn't have alienated Rodman by chasing him around with a bible. He would have been grateful for the 15 rebounds per game Rodman got for his team and he would have been OK with Rodman leaving his house on the weekend.

[Nathan89]

Resort to ring smack when you get ed up the ass in an argument

You've just showed the forum that you're just as ty of a poster as cully

No dip he said he was going to stick to facts and then claimed that David had zero rings. I would have never brought up rings otherwise.

[Nathan89]

proof?

link?

I already addressed this issue.

[Veterinarian.]

No dip he said he was going to stick to facts and then claimed that David had zero rings. I would have never brought up rings otherwise.

Are you in stupid? He is arguing about winning rings as the main guy, the number 1 you dip . Even a in chimp like koolaid could read that.

No one gives a about robinsons two rings that he rode to get. Fact is, he could not get it done when it mattered and his highlight of his career was getting ass raped by Dream

[Monostradamus]

Not fact but it's pretty obvious. Do you speculate otherwise?

Actually those aren't facts
Dirk 1
D-Rob 2

D-Rob 2 as a supporting cast member
Perdue 4 as a supporting cast member

Will Perdue, greatest center in Spurs history!

[Monostradamus]

Although Dirks offensive stats may be better than Davids, he has always been horrible on defense. The stars aligned for the Mavs at the right time. Terry didnt choke. Dirk played tough. Kidd was a steady leader. Cuban shut the up. They figured it out. For the first time the Mavs were the hunters, and not thw hunted. David was a much better all around player and id still take him over Dirk even though the highlight of his career was getting ted on by Hakeem. Midget made some good points about Robinson, but he went too far with the Dirk comparisons. A prime David could guard a prime Dirk. A prime Dirk gets drug by a prime David.

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

1997 Spurs with Dirk instead of D-Rob

Will Purdue
Dirk
Dominique Wilkins
Sean Elliott
Avery Johnson

w/ Vernon Maxwell as the 6th man


STAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACKED

[Nathan89]

IMO Dirk could have easily won a championship with Dominique Wilkins and Sean Elliott.

So you think Dirk could win a championship with Wilkins(who was 37,shot .417fg%,avg 18ppg) and Sean (15ppg, on .422fg%). This would have been against Jordan(goat) and Pippen(top 50 all-time).

But Dirk couldn't win it in 2006 when Terry(17ppg on 47%fg) and Howard(15.6ppg on .471fg%).

IMO terrible post.

[Isitjustme?]

I think that in their careers if you swap Dirk with David, the Spurs are worse and the Mavs are better, yes.

[Nathan89]

Was merely stating that you weren't posting the facts you were claiming to.

[Monostradamus]

So you think Dirk could win a championship with Wilkins(who was 37,shot .417fg%,avg 18ppg) and Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Lu ck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_(15p pg, on .422fg%). This would have been against Jordan(goat) and Pippen(top 50 all-time).

But Dirk couldn't win it in 2006 when Terry(17ppg on 47%fg) and Howard(15.6ppg on .471fg%).

IMO terrible post.

can't even spell Elliott right. What kind of ty Spurs fan are you?

[DUNCANownsKOBE]

So you think Dirk could win a championship with Wilkins(who was 37,shot .417fg%,avg 18ppg) and Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Lu ck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_Luck_The_Fakers_(15p pg, on .422fg%). This would have been against Jordan(goat) and Pippen(top 50 all-time).

But Dirk couldn't win it in 2006 when Terry(17ppg on 47%fg) and Howard(15.6ppg on .471fg%).

IMO terrible post.

Funny, when Spurfan talks about 2011 Jason Kidd as a great in supporting cast member, his old age isn't mentioned at all, but you were quick to point out Wilkins' old age. Gotta love the double standard.

[Monostradamus]

Bynum 2
Mavs 1

[Nathan89]

can't even spell Elliott right. What kind of ty Spurs fan are you?

yes I see that.

Are you going to stick to fact now?

[Monostradamus]

Every argument Spurs fans have in this thread is "I think...."

"I think D-Rob would have made the Mavs better"
"I think D-Rob could have led the Mavs to a le"
"I think Dirk would have made the Spurs worse"

How about posting what you know?

I know two things.

1. Dirk led his team to a le.
2. Robinson never did.

[Nathan89]

Funny, when Spurfan talks about 2011 Jason Kidd as a great in supporting cast member, his old age isn't mentioned at all, but you were quick to point out Wilkins' old age. Gotta love the double standard.

I didn't mention Kidd.

[Monostradamus]

yes I see that.

Are you going to stick to fact now?

2 facts.

1. Dirk led his team to a le.
2. Robinson never did.

[Monostradamus]

Pau 2
Dirk 1

Its settled

[Nathan89]

2 facts.

1. Dirk led his team to a le.
2. Robinson never did.

Do you think Dirk would have won on the Spurs?