Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 35
  1. 01-14-2019 #1
    Ghazi
    Veteran
    My Team
    San Francisco 49ers
    Post Count
    14,577
    Uhh so like I was bored and trying to Google this and there's so many different types of lists so uhh who are the top 5 QBs ever wtf?

    1. Brady 2. Montana . ... 3-5?

    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Ghazi is offline
  2. 01-14-2019 #2
    spurraider21
    Savvy Veteran spurraider21's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    100,825
    there isn't really a consensus. i think people acknowledge that brady/montana are the top 2. nostalgic old farts put montana up there, everybody else has brady by this point.

    after that, i'd probably still say peyton manning. even with his postseason shortcomings in mind, his greatness was on another level. his body of work is goat-worthy which at some point has to matter.

    i'd go brees/rodgers/marino/favre after that. next tier is the "winners" who weren't quite as prolific, as in elway/aikman. they have clutch moments but spend most of their careers throwing like 17 touchdowns per year . you can talk all you want about eras, but those numbers were pedestrian even during those times
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote spurraider21 is offline
  3. 01-14-2019 #3
    Blake
    right about pizzagate Blake's Avatar
    My Team
    Baltimore Ravens
    Post Count
    83,739
    No clue about Unitas but the ones I've seen:

    1. Brady
    2. Elway
    3. Manning
    4. Montana
    5. Brees
    6. Chad Henne
    7. Quincy Carter
    8. Mahomes
    9. Billy Joe Tolliver
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Blake is offline
  4. 01-14-2019 #4
    FrostKing
    coffee's for closers FrostKing's Avatar
    My Team
    San Francisco 49ers
    Post Count
    19,410
    Quarterbacks I've watched

    1. Montana
    2. Brady
    3. Manning
    4. Favre
    5. Brees, Elway, Rodgers, Young
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote FrostKing is offline
  5. 01-14-2019 #5
    Cuppycake Gumdrop
    you're my sweetie pie Cuppycake Gumdrop's Avatar
    Post Count
    1,217
    Yeah, Brady/Montana/Peyton is the undisputed top 3, after that it's pretty much whoever you personally prefer. My 4 and 5 go to Steve Young and Brees.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Cuppycake Gumdrop is offline
  6. 01-14-2019 #6
    JohnnyMax
    Veteran
    My Team
    Kansas City Chiefs
    Post Count
    3,192
    1 Rodgers
    2 Mahomes
    3 Favre
    4 Manning
    5 Montana

    Cheaters are automatically disqualified

    Source: https://www.footballdb.com/stats/qb-...html?type=post
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote JohnnyMax is offline
  7. 01-14-2019 #7
    Will Hunting
    4-25-20 Will Hunting's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    22,468
    Quote Originally Posted by JohnnyMax
    1 Rodgers
    2 Mahomes
    3 Favre
    4 Manning
    5 Montana

    Cheaters are automatically disqualified

    Source: https://www.footballdb.com/stats/qb-...html?type=post
    If cheaters are disqualified then why do you have PED user Manning on the list?
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Will Hunting is offline
  8. 01-14-2019 #8
    Will Hunting
    4-25-20 Will Hunting's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    22,468
    Quote Originally Posted by Blake
    No clue about Unitas but the ones I've seen:

    1. Brady
    2. Elway
    3. Manning
    4. Montana
    5. Brees
    6. Chad Henne
    7. Quincy Carter
    8. Mahomes
    9. Billy Joe Tolliver
    sorry, but the Chad Henne joke has been dead since naldo man stopped posting on this site
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Will Hunting is offline
  9. 01-14-2019 #9
    spurraider21
    Savvy Veteran spurraider21's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    100,825
    none of the stone age qb's belong on the list
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote spurraider21 is offline
  10. 01-14-2019 #10
    MultiTroll
    Believe.
    Post Count
    24,896
    Montana
    Elway
    Red Grange
    Manning
    Brady
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote MultiTroll is offline
  11. 01-14-2019 #11
    Mitch
    Executive Mitch's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    6,573
    There should be a separate list for the old timer QBs like Unitas, tbh.

    It's generally

    1. Brady
    2. Montana
    3. Manning

    and then you have a debate
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Mitch is offline
  12. 01-14-2019 #12
    Fabbs
    Believe. Fabbs's Avatar
    Post Count
    15,577
    Quote Originally Posted by JohnnyMax
    1 Rodgers
    2 Mahomes
    3 Favre
    4 Manning
    5 Montana

    Cheaters are automatically disqualified

    Source: https://www.footballdb.com/stats/qb-...html?type=post
    Lets not forget the greatness of Brady.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Fabbs is offline
  13. 01-14-2019 #13
    Fabbs
    Believe. Fabbs's Avatar
    Post Count
    15,577
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Fabbs is offline
  14. 01-14-2019 #14
    HarlemHeat37
    Veteran
    Post Count
    42,293
    Ranking NFL players is essentially ranking schemes and supporting casts, tbh
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote HarlemHeat37 is offline
  15. 01-14-2019 #15
    MultiTroll
    Believe.
    Post Count
    24,896
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote MultiTroll is offline
  16. 01-15-2019 #16
    Blake
    right about pizzagate Blake's Avatar
    My Team
    Baltimore Ravens
    Post Count
    83,739
    Quote Originally Posted by Will Hunting
    sorry, but the Chad Henne joke has been dead since naldo man stopped posting on this site
    Just pouring one out for Henne.

    I miss him almost as much as Toby Keith American Patriot.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Blake is offline
  17. 01-15-2019 #17
    spurraider21
    Savvy Veteran spurraider21's Avatar
    My Team
    Oakland Raiders
    Post Count
    100,825
    Quote Originally Posted by Fabbs
    Lets not forget the greatness of Brady.
    Quote Originally Posted by Fabbs
    one of the worst calls in NFL history*

    but he's still the GOAT. he's done it time and time again after the tuck, and its not like he was anywhere near his peak during those days anyway.


    *and no, it's not the case of "it was a stupid rule, but they made the right call." no, not only was it a stupid rule, but it was the wrong call anyway. he had already completed the whole pump fake and had both hands on the ball at the time woodson knocked it out. so yeah, he tucked it, finished the tuck, then got stripped. just because you pump fake once doesn't mean you're immune from fumbling the rest of the play

    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote spurraider21 is offline
  18. 01-15-2019 #18
    Ghazi
    Veteran
    My Team
    San Francisco 49ers
    Post Count
    14,577
    Quote Originally Posted by HarlemHeat37
    Ranking NFL players is essentially ranking schemes and supporting casts, tbh
    True to an extent but could apply to any sport tbh
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Ghazi is offline
  19. 01-15-2019 #19
    Chris
    non-essential Chris's Avatar
    My Team
    Dallas Cowboys
    Post Count
    39,908
    Quote Originally Posted by JohnnyMax
    Cheaters are automatically disqualified
    Let us proceed...
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Chris is offline
  20. 01-16-2019 #20
    BD24
    VanillaPlayerFan BD24's Avatar
    My Team
    Green Bay Packers
    Post Count
    6,605
    1. Brady
    2. Montana
    3. Rodgers
    4. Young
    5. Manning
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote BD24 is offline
  21. 01-26-2019 #21
    Bull True
    Banned
    Post Count
    27
    1. Young
    2. Marino
    3. Favre
    4. Rodgers
    5. Rivers / Roethlisburger
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Bull True is offline
  22. 01-26-2019 #22
    Play Boban
    BLACK LIVES MATTER Play Boban's Avatar
    Post Count
    5,005
    1. 41-year old GOAT Brady
    2. 40-year old GOAT Brady
    3. 25-year old GOAT Brady
    4. 38-year old GOAT Brady
    5. 30-year old GOAT Brady
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Play Boban is offline
  23. 01-26-2019 #23
    Raven
    Veteran Raven's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    17,954
    at this point one has to wonder what does rodgers have to do, for accountability to sink in...
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Raven is offline
  24. 01-26-2019 #24
    Will Hunting
    4-25-20 Will Hunting's Avatar
    My Team
    New England Patriots
    Post Count
    22,468
    Quote Originally Posted by Raven
    at this point one has to wonder what does rodgers have to do, for accountability to sink in...
    I put him top 10 and not top 5 as of right now. Peak Aaron Rodgers was maybe the most unguardable QB aid all time, but if last year was any indication the longevity won’t be there. He isn’t going to last into his late 30s or 40s unless he changes his game and relies less on being able to play heroball.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Will Hunting is offline
  25. 01-26-2019 #25
    Chucho
    Veteran
    Post Count
    12,071
    Cant take you serious if you put Young over Peyton.
    Reply With Quote Reply With Quote Chucho is offline
« Previous Thread | Next Thread »

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Forum Rules